Jump to content


Member Since 18 Apr 2012
Offline Last Active Sep 02 2014 10:23 PM

Topics I've Started

France's Constitutional Court approves Hollande's "Millionaire Tax"

30 December 2013 - 08:08 PM



France’s 75% millionaire tax approved by country’s high court

French President Francois Hollande received approval from the country’s constitutional court to proceed with his plan to tax salaries above 1 million euros at 75% for this year and next.

Under Hollande’s proposal, companies will have to pay a 50% duty on wages above 1 million euros (US$1.4-million). In combination with other taxes and social charges, the rate will amount to 75% of salaries above the threshold, the court wrote in a decision published today.

“The companies that pay out remuneration above 1 million euros will, as expected, be called upon for an effort of solidarity on remuneration paid in 2013 and 2014,” the Economy Ministry said in an e-mailed statement.

Hollande, who once said he “didn’t like” the rich, announced the 75% tax in February 2012 as part of his presidential campaign to appeal to his Socialist base. It has become a symbol of his government’s record-high taxation rate.

A first proposal to put the change into law was turned down by the constitutional court in December last year because the tax applied to individuals and not households. The country’s top administrative court said any rate above 66% would be rejected as confiscatory.

Hollande revived the plan this year, making it apply to salaries and be paid by employers rather than individuals. The total amount is limited to 5% of a company’s revenue.

The court examined the proposed tax after more than 60 members of parliament and more than 60 senators filed their opposition, it said.

The tax is expected to affect about 470 companies and a dozen soccer clubs, and is forecast to raise approximately 210 million euros a year.

The Constitutional Council, a court comprising judges and former French presidents, has the power to annul laws if they are deemed to violate the constitution.


Tax increases designed to reduce France’s budget deficit have fuelled rising discontent in the country, with recent polls giving Hollande the lowest approval rating of any French president on record.

His 2012 supertax election pledge infuriated high earners in France and prompted actor Gerard Depardieu to flee the country. It has also alienated entrepreneurs and foreign investors, who have accused Hollande of being anti-business.

Hollande has said that the wealthy should contribute more to help to repair the country’s finances, arguing that the supertax should also encourage companies to curb excessive executive pay.

In Sunday’s ruling, the Constitutional Council rejected planned wealth tax measures that it said imposed levies on potential gains — such as those on life insurance policies — and thus risked overestimating a taxpayer’s actual resources.

It also quashed several measures designed to crack down on tax avoidance schemes through which individuals and companies use legal loopholes to minimise their tax bills.

One of the proposed measures required consultants and firms offering tax planning services to disclose such schemes before marketing them. The council found the provision was too vague and ran counter to freedom of entrepreneurship.

Compiled with files from Bloomberg.com, Reuters

Notes: Only a court approval, nothing being legislated yet. Because of Hollande's rising disapproval rating the right are beginning to control the lower house in France, making it difficult for this to pass. As well, this is a 75% tax on wages (not corporations) and only that earned above 1M is taxed.

When the British attempted this at 90% in the 1960s many either found loopholes or moved to the Channel Islands. I believe when America introduced a similar measure loopholes were so abundant that it had little to no effect. Many French are either relocating to Belgium or Quebec.

Spengler Cup

27 December 2013 - 04:49 PM

This year's tournament is more important than usual as a full AHL team (Rochester) has gone over. So far they've lost 5-0 to Geneva (Swiss League) and 4-3 to CSKA (KHL). Interesting comparison of league levels and competitiveness. Normally we aren't given too many opportunities to see how NA teams stack up against their European counterparts.

Line brawl in Women's USA/Canada exhibition game

21 December 2013 - 02:17 PM


:canada: :flag: